Case one
A Bay Area SFR rolled into an East Austin duplex.
Marcus owned a 1,400-square-foot single-family rental in Oakland that he purchased in 2014 for $585,000. By March of 2026 he sold it for $1,180,000. His basis after depreciation sat at roughly $490,000, which put his deferred federal gain and depreciation recapture obligation near $690,000. Without a 1031, that tax bill would have landed close to $190,000 in his next return.
Marcus's Qualified Intermediary took constructive receipt of the proceeds on April 3, the day the Oakland sale funded. From that moment, he had until May 18 to deliver a written list of replacement properties and until September 30 to close on one of them. He engaged Luke on April 7. Four days to catch up on a market he had never worked in.
Luke spent the first week pulling every East Austin duplex priced between $900,000 and $1,250,000 that had been on the market long enough to negotiate. Nine properties survived the first cut. Marcus flew in on April 15 for a two-day tour. By April 22 they had identified three properties under the 3-Property Rule and submitted an offer on a 2008-built duplex in 78721, close to the Mueller submarket, listed at $1,095,000. It closed on June 12 at $1,035,000, well inside the 180-day window.
Marcus rolled every dollar of Oakland equity into the duplex, took on slightly more debt to meet the equal-or-greater requirement, and avoided the $190,000 tax bill completely. The duplex rents both sides at a combined $5,400 per month. The California Franchise Tax Board filed a Form 3840 reminder in the fall, which his CPA responded to.