The rubric
The nine-point scorecard.
Point one: segregated qualified escrow or qualified trust accounts for every client. The QI should hold your money in an account titled with your name and the exchange reference, not pooled with other clients. Ask for the account structure in writing before you sign.
Point two: Fidelity bond and errors-and-omissions insurance with combined coverage of at least $1 million. Request the certificate. Verify the policy is current, not expired.
Point three: at least seven years of continuous operation under the same ownership. New entities and recent ownership changes are not automatic disqualifiers but they shift risk upward.
Point four: a named Certified Exchange Specialist (CES) on staff, credentialed through the Federation of Exchange Accommodators. CES is the industry's professional certification and the only one that carries any meaningful continuing education requirement.
Point five: explicit written statement that the QI is not disqualified under Treasury Regulation 1.1031(k)-1(k). A QI who has acted as your agent, employee, attorney, accountant, broker, or realtor within the prior two years is disqualified by rule. Any ambiguity here voids the exchange.
Point six: a sample exchange agreement provided before engagement. If the QI will not share paperwork until you commit, that is itself diagnostic. The agreement should spell out fund handling, interest allocation, release conditions, and dispute resolution venue.
Point seven: direct response time of under four business hours during the 45-day identification window and under two hours during the five business days before close. Ask for the specific person who will handle your exchange and their coverage schedule.
Point eight: Texas jurisdiction clause in the agreement, or, failing that, a jurisdiction the investor can realistically litigate in. Agreements that select the QI's home state as the sole venue become unhelpful fast if anything goes wrong.
Point nine: fee transparency in a written quote before engagement, with interest on held funds either paid to the exchanger at a stated rate or disclosed as retained by the QI with the rate it will be invested at.